In the operating theatre at Friendship Hospital in Gaza City, two MSF surgeons were ninety minutes into what was meant to be a ninety-minute operation, but struggling with what they had found. The patient’s shin had been shattered by an Israeli bullet, the bone shredded and a big chunk of flesh blown away. The plan had been to take some healthy muscle from the calf to help fill the wound. However, once Camille Rodaix and Jan Wynands, the two MSF surgeons, opened the calf they found that the muscle there was also damaged: riddled with bits of shrapnel and toughened by areas of scar tissue.
The problem the two surgeons were trying to treat has reached epidemic proportions in Gaza recently. Since the end of March, the “Great March of Return” protests have seen over 150 Palestinians shot dead by the Israeli army, as well as over 4100 injured by Israeli bullets. Since the protests began MSF has treated over 1,700 patients, nearly all of them with gunshot wounds. The majority of these wounds were caused over just 23 days within the last four months, as most protests and Israel’s subsequent response take place on the Friday of each week. MSF is still receiving new patients as violence has not stopped, although it is now happening on a smaller scale. Still, hundreds of Palestinian protesters are wounded every week at the fence, and a few are killed.
“The injuries that we see are characterised by a high prevalence of open fractures – most below the knee – with massive tissue loss, which means damage to the veins and nerves as well,” says Marie-Elisabeth Ingres, MSF’s head of mission. “Many of these patients require multiple surgeries just to close the wound.”
That was the aim with the patient on the table at Friendship. “My goal is to stabilise the wound so that we can see if the bone will heal,” Camille, an orthopaedic surgeon, said as she inspected the patient’s leg, the wound on which was still raw nearly two months after the patient had been shot. An external fixator – a metal rod attached at right angles to pins drilled into the remaining parts of the bone – was keeping the shattered parts of the bone in place. “I operated on this patient before to remove a bone fragment that was sticking up into the skin,” Camille explained, “and now I will work with Jan – a plastic surgeon – to check for any remaining bits of dead bone and to close the wound.” Though this was not the patient’s first operation, it would also not be his last: the orthopaedic surgery necessary to permanently heal the wound is “really hard,” says Camille. “We don’t have the tools to do it, and we cannot try to fix the bone while the wound is still open anyway.”
The stakes for patients like the one Camille and Jan were operating on are high. With a health system that has been crippled by more than ten years of an Israeli blockade and Palestinian political infighting, the specialist surgeries that many of these patients need are unavailable, raising the spectre that they will be disabled for life.
Each morning at five clinics in the Gaza Strip a succession of MSF vans pull up and discharge waves of young men, awkwardly slinging themselves out of the vehicles while holding legs forced straight by a tangle of metal. They pick their crutches from the pile that have tumbled together and propel themselves through the doors. Inside, rows of patients wait to be seen, their external fixators sticking through tracksuit bottoms lovingly stitched to have Velcro flaps that allow for the trousers to come on and off, without disturbing the pins stuck into the bone beneath.
It is in these clinics that MSF is changing dressings and providing physiotherapy, on a scale that reflects the staggering quantity and severity of the injuries. Since 30 March 2018, MSF has carried out over 40,000 appointments to change dressings for trauma patients, helping those who can to recover and keeping an eye on people whose injuries means they require further surgery.
“I didn’t feel anything at first, when I got shot,” says Raed Bordini, 24, from al Maghazi camp. “There was just a flash of something like electricity, I sat down suddenly and found I couldn’t move. I was trying to pull myself back but I couldn’t. I was bleeding a lot, and I was scared of the effects on my leg because it was all open – cut open from the back to the front.” Raed comes to the clinic multiple times a week for dressing changes and his external fixator is still in. “I am in a lot of pain,” he says. “I take a lot of things like ibuprofen and paracetamol but it has no effect. I am scared the function won’t return to my leg. It scares that I’m not able to stand on it, I can see that it’s not right.”
Dawlet Hamidiyyeh, 33, is one of the comparatively few female patients that MSF is treating for a gunshot wound. She attends the Beit Lahia clinic in a wheelchair, her leg stuck out straight in front of her. “It was the first time I went to the fence,” she says of the 14 May, the deadliest day of protests. “I wanted to see what was happening. I brought the guys some water and some perfume for the effects of the gas. After I was shot I was taken to the Indonesian hospital, my eyes were open but I couldn’t see, but I could hear everything. The people thought I was dead. They put me in the morgue at the hospital, but after ten minutes one of the doctors noticed I was alive and started shouting that I had a pulse.” Now she has to come to the clinic three times a week to have her dressings changed. Her external fixator will be in for at least five months, and she is also fearful for her future. “I’m scared that I won’t be like before, that I won’t be able to walk.”
Unfortunately, the worries of many patients like Raed and Dawlet will turn out to be justified. “We will probably see a second wave of amputations,” says Pascale Marty, MSF’s medical team leader in Gaza. “Gunshot wounds are by definition contaminated wounds, because the bullet has entered the wound, meaning that there is a high prevalence of infection.” Infected open fractures of such complexity pose a threat to the life of the patient, leaving little other choice but to amputate if reconstructive surgery is not an option.
While such severe wounds and high rates of infection would generally require that the patient be admitted to hospital, the overburdened health system in Gaza cannot accommodate such a high number of patients. Mohammed Abu Gaza, 25, was shot on 6 April near Rafah. His knee shattered, but he was repeatedly discharged from the hospital. “Six days after I was shot I was discharged to make space for the wounded from the next Friday,” he says. “I kept going back to the hospital with fever and pain but they wouldn’t admit me, because they were full.” After being referred by MSF to a different hospital, he had another operation but eventually the same thing happened: “I stayed one week there, but then they discharged me again to make way for the next wave of wounded.”
The effects of the wounds are thus rippling out through Gaza’s population burdening the wider society with the costs and responsibilities of care, in a place where the years of occupation, war and blockade have brought the economy to the brink of collapse. Unemployment among the 15-29 age group – which makes up two-thirds of MSF’s patients – has reached 60 percent, according to the World Bank. Families have either lost a source of income, or for those that already had to support their unemployed members, they are now bearing the extra load of their care.
“Before I was injured I sometimes sold vegetables from a cart in the market, but it was only enough to bring me money for cigarettes,” says Mohammed. “Now I just sit in the house – I can’t do anything by myself, even washing. I have to ask the family for help with everything.” Another patient, A, who was shot on 30 March, described how his father, a government employee, had to borrow $1,500 from relatives in order to pay for the treatment he needed. “Before, sometimes I worked with my friends and relatives on building sites. I really miss this. I am not able to earn money now. My relatives abroad are sending money for my treatment.”
The consequences are not just economic, however. As well being a hairdresser, a job she had worked at for the past ten years, Dawlet was a caregiver for her sick father. “It hurts me that I can’t help my dad,” she says, “now I need care as well as him.” The accumulation of physical pain, financial stress and social pressures is causing mental difficulties for many of the patients. “It’s hard 24-hours a day, I’m just sitting in the house. Honestly it’s destroyed my life, and the life of my family,” Dawlet says, downcast.
While protests continue on the border every weekend and some Palestinians continue to be killed and injured by the Israeli army, the numbers are fewer. Yet the nature of the violence has evolved and escalated in recent weeks, resulting in the death of one Israeli soldier in mid-July, and continuing deaths and injuries amongst Palestinians. Over two months have passed since the days of the heaviest casualties, a period of time that would see normal fractures heal. For many of those in Gaza, progress has not nearly been so quick, due to the complexity of their injuries. “They will need five to six months to heal, if they heal at all,” says Camille, the orthopaedic surgeon. “Our patients can be divided into three groups, of roughly equal sizes: those who will eventually heal, those who will need extra surgeries to heal and those who will need specialist reconstructive surgery over the course of years if they are to have any chance of healing.” This type of surgery is unavailable in Gaza though, leaving many people facing the possibility that they will never regain the function of their limbs.
Back at Friendship hospital, Camille and Jan had succeeded in pulling across the section of muscle they needed to fill the wound after some tense moments. A section of the skin from the thigh had been grafted onto the wound to close it, and the team started to relax as the long hours of surgery came to an end. “This operation was representative of the fact that you think, ‘this is not so bad’,” said Camille, “but the wounds are so bad here that you never know what you will find inside.” She was hopeful that the patient would manage to avoid further infection with the wound closed. However, for him and many others, with bones missing and the blockade in place, the long-term future is far from certain.
MSF East Africa
MSF East Africa